Baseball, Bar Fights, and Bad Guys – Aronofsky Goes Full Noir with Austin Butler & Zoë Kravitz in First Trailer for Caught Stealing

When Darren Aronofsky makes a movie, you never quite know what you’re going to get. But one thing’s for sure: it won’t be boring. And with Caught Stealing, it looks like he’s poured whiskey, baseball, and punk rock into his usual cocktail of existential dread and visual bravado — for the first time.

A Fallen Baseball Star… and a Cat

Austin Butler (still oozing sweaty cool since Elvis) plays Hank Thompson, a former baseball talent now stuck pouring beers at a New York bar and hanging out with his girlfriend — played by Zoë Kravitz, who brings her usual sharp edge and offbeat energy to the screen.

It all starts innocently enough: his neighbor — a punk rocker played by Matt Smith — asks him to look after his cat. But as we all know: in Aronofsky’s world, even the smallest favor can spiral into chaos.

Soon Hank is knee-deep in gangsters, shady characters, and pure mayhem, with everyone chasing him and no one willing to explain why. So he runs, hides, and punches his way through a story that feels like After Hours, The Big Lebowski, and a hungover Tarantino flick rolled into one.

The Cast: Loaded with Style and Swagger

This cast isn’t just solid — it’s downright intriguing:

• Austin Butler as the cool but cursed lead
• Zoë Kravitz as his loyal, razor-sharp partner
• Matt Smith in the classic “it’s-not-my-fault-but-it-totally-is” sidekick role
• Regina King, Vincent D’Onofrio, Liev Schreiber, Carol Kane, Benito A Martínez Ocasio (Bad Bunny) and Griffin Dunne round out a cast bursting with personality and punch

You can already feel it: this won’t be your typical Hollywood recipe. It reeks of gritty ‘90s energy and busted-up charm. Bottles are thrown, phones are screamed into, and dark alleys are sprinted down — with blood on faces and no clear way out.

Aronofsky’s First Film Since The Whale

Caught Stealing marks Aronofsky’s first film since The Whale, and it’s a clear genre pivot — from heavy Oscar drama to a dirt-under-the-nails action-noir-comedy. The screenplay is by Charlie Huston, based on his own novel. (Yes, the same Charlie Huston who’s worked with Marvel and Netflix.)

When and Where?

No official release date yet, but with the trailer out and press already heating up, Caught Stealing is clearly primed to hit theaters in full force by fall 2025.

Watch the trailer below:

Our team may have used AI to assist in the creation of this content, which has been reviewed by our editors.